Shingle Comparison Chart

Best overall shingle: CertainTeed, Landmark PRO

Best overall value: BP, Everest 42

Best algae resistance: Malarkey, Highlander CS

BEST Shingle Adhesion: BP, Everest 42

BEST Nailing Area: Malarkey, Highlander CS

BEST Wind Warranty: BP, Everest 42

WORST Overall Score: GAF TL Natural Shadow & Owens Corning Oakridge had the lowest scores.